reviews & comments
The tabloid headline screams: "Ottoman Empire Lives!
Secret Outposts Found in Canada!" A put-on? Not in the least, if the musicians
on Balkan Journeys Close to Home have anything to say about it. And indeed
they do beginning with the Bulgarian bands Staro Selo and Neda Voda, then
fast-forwarding to the string trio Mastika and the trans-Balkan/Turkish
Altin Yildiz Orkestar, the spirit of their music is captured in one title
"Rod Serling's Trip to Bulgaria." Sound a little wacko? Well, maybe, but
it turns out that Toronto is a hotbed of things Eastern, as if there was
one huge, non-stop Turko-jam going on. According to annotator and vocalist
Brenna MacCrimmon, that's truer than many residents know. The reason?
Huge immigrant communities from Greece, Bulgaria, Macedonia, Albania,
Turkey you get the picture.
But what does it all mean? One hard-charging, string-searing
album, replete with reworkings of classic Macedonian, Turkish, Albanian
and you-name-it, the Ottomans governed it, we-got-it tunes. The highlights
start with the tight vocal harmonies of Staro Selo and just keep on going
my favorite track is the Altin Yildiz Orkestar's ultra-hot version of
the notorious Gypsy song, "Rumelai". In sum, Balkan Journeys... is a moveable
feast of virtuosity and dementia, a must-have for fans of pan-Turkish
music.
Ellen Collison, Dirty Linen (#87, April & May 2000)
My initial impression of this compilation of Balkan and
Central European music from the exotic Canadian village of Toronto was,
"nice, but it all sounds kinda the same." Over the past few
years, I've developed a taste for the crazed dance numbers set to complex
time signatures ("these are professional 11/8 dancers; don't try
this at home!") of Balkan music, as well as the more stately sounds
of Turkish court music. So I listened again. And again. And realized how
wrong I was. "Balkan Journeys Close to Home" presents different
aspects of this fascinating music from a quartet of combos sharing an
evolving cast of players, a retrospective charting the development of
the wonderful Toronto
band Maza Mezé.
The earliest constellation here, Staro Selo, offers the
most demented, joyous rhythms, and features the harmony vocals of Brenna
MacCrimmon and Jayne Brown, tight, nasal, and suggestive of a scaled-down
Voix Bulgares, one voice tending to a drone complementing the melody,
the vocal equivalent of bagpipes. The 11/8 whirlpool of "Grabile
Smiljana Devoika" is dizzying, the glottal stops and yips of the
vocalists echoing and echoed by the pipe and flute instrumentation, grounded
in sparse yet lively darabuka percussion and strummed tambura.
Mastika, a trio, presents similar music in an calmer
instrumental context. "Lupchevo" toes the same 11/8 beat as
"Grabile Smiljana Devoika," but with focus on bouzouki and the
tambura, a two-stringed mandolin. And is it any surprise that "Rod
Serling's Trip to Bulgaria," a wild elaboration of the "Twilight
Zone" theme, should appear on CD as we approach the millennium? Coincidence?
Or conspiracy!?
The Mastika guys were probably playing concurrently in
Neda Voda with vocalist Brenna MacCrimmon and, despite the recurrent complex
rhythms, this band presents a much calmer, reflective, more stately image
than Staro Selo. "O Gospozo," a Rom (gypsy) song, is notably
sad and plaintive, and even the more lively 7/8 Macedonian song "Taja
Vecer Ic Ne Sum Vesela" finds MacCrimmon's vocal in a melancholy
mood.
The Altin Yildiz Orkestar is the largest of the four
bands on "Balkan Journeys Close to Home," with the richest combination
of sounds, instrumental and vocal. MacCrimmon's vocal (yep, she's in this
band too, and also wrote the liner notes) is backed in depth on "Rumelaj,"
a slower dramatic song in what at this point seems an exotic concept,
common time, and also enjoys violin accompaniment. Sax and clarinet join
on the lively "Chiftetelli #6," a Greek instrumental framed
by an undulating melodic figure redolent of caravans, tents, and spices,
and featuring jazzy solos.
No, they don't all sound the same, but there are marked
similarities in the evolving bands highlighted on "Balkan Journeys
Close to Home," and all fine listening.
Disclaimer: I have no financial interest in this act.
Hell, I've never even seen them perform, and don't know them, and can't
even reliably count out an 11/8 beat. I am not paid in advance to write
reviews, although on rare occasions someone will pay me for use rights
after the fact. If this is hype, then ALL speech is hype.
Jim Foley - Music Director, KXCI-FM, Tucson AZ
Every so often a special recording arrives in your life.
You realize from the first listening that it is something you will revisit
over the months and years ahead. "Balkan Journeys Close to Home"
is such an album. Soon to be released on the Golden Horn label, this CD
brings together over 71 minutes of wonderful sounds in 19 instrumental
and vocal selections from four Balkan-style ensembles that have emerged
in Toronto over the past decade.
The accompanying booklet is attractively designed and
provides useful and interesting information on specific pieces, ensembles,
and the creative process. Brenna MacCrimmon's note entitled "Toronto,
Macedonia" establishes the context for the genesis of these performances:
"Well all right, I suppose if you look on a map you'll see that Toronto
is not in Macedonia but somewhere in Southern Ontario, Canada. I said
that to draw attention to the fact that over the last hundred years or
so thousands of immigrants, Greeks, Slavs and Albanians, from the ever
strife torn Balkan territories made their way to this part of the world,
to work in the mines and the forests of Ontario's north and to help build
the infrastructure of cities like Toronto. Call the force whatever you
will, America's Melting Pot or Canada's Kaleidoscope, as much as it encouraged
assimilation it allowed for various groups to maintain some of the cultural
aspects of their homeland. What this has meant for those of us interested
in more that just the music we grew up with (whatever that music might
be) is that we have only to go as far as the next restaurant, night club,
community center, summer festival or picnic to sample a taste both musical
and gastronomic of other cultures. And that's where this recording begins,
with a group of Balkan folk music lovers, some music students and community
folk musicians who began to sing and play together ..."
The ensembles are Staro Selo, Neda Voda, Mastika and
Altin Yildiz Orkestar. Some 22 performers appear in the various ensembles,
and some (for example, Brenna MacCrimmon and Ben Grossman) appear in more
than one. One of the remarkable elements of the Toronto music scene has
been the comfortable cross-over and experimentation that has allowed talented
artists from a variety of backgrounds (ethnically diverse, formal and
informal musical education, diverse musical genres, professional and semi-professional,
etc.) to come together and explore old and new forms in a variety of performance
contexts. For example, more than half the members of the Maza Meze ensemble
appear on this recording. When I played "Balkan Journeys" for
George Sawa - an ex-Alexandrian who through his educational and performance
work has fostered the appreciation of Arab and Near/Middle Eastern music
in Canada - he was thrilled with the sound and the presence of many of
his former students.
The musical material is derived from a variety of sources.
The notes suggest that while some pieces are learned from another musician,
there are many which have been inspired by such sources as a "cassette
of Razlog Rom singer Tsetsa" or "a large stack of 45 rpm from
Jugoslavia". The performances are not slavish attempts to duplicate
the source material. Rather, the original melodies, rhythmic and text
elements inspire a fresh approach. The result is a highly enjoyable and
the in-concert performances, in particular, capture the fun and informal
dynamic between the performers and their loyal audience. I believe the
recording will be available in stores shortly, and that Festival Distribution
in Canada has picked it up for our market. For those who enjoyed Mercan
Dede's "Sufi Dreams" on the same label, this gives you another
opportunity to hear Brenna MacCrimmonís vocal work. She is a remarkable
artist who has maintained her Toronto connections while living in Istanbul
and exploring in considerable depth the musical traditions of Turkey and
neighbouring regions. This summer she is organizing a Canadian visit by
a Thracian wedding band, and the group will appear at several festivals
during July.
This message has been much longer than anticipated, but
that is probably an accurate gauge of my enthusiasm for it. For people
facing a long drive it is perfect; three times through and you've gone
from Ottawa to Toronto with a smile on your face the whole time.
Ron McRae
Consultant Producer, Performing Arts
The Canadian Museum of Civilization
|